Home Opinion NBA MUST HOLD THE SCALES OF ETHICS EVENLY BY JIBRIN OKUTEPA

NBA MUST HOLD THE SCALES OF ETHICS EVENLY BY JIBRIN OKUTEPA

by Editor

A Nigerian lawyer has been dragged before the LPDC for allegedly using insulting language against a judge. The NBA filed the complaint. I do not want to engage in the political arguments surrounding the complaint.

That is not my intention. The NBA has a duty to make complaints. The LPDC was established to adjudicate complaints of professional misconduct. There is no doubt about that. Let me be clear from the beginning: no lawyer should insult a judge. An advocate’s responsibility carries a duty of restraint, even in the face of profound disagreement with a judicial decision.

But using abusive language on national television against judicial officers is not the only form of professional misconduct. What has the NBA done about some lawyers in politics who have consistently admitted on national television to influencing judicial decisions? Is that not professional misconduct? Be that as it may, lawyers may expose errors, challenge reasoning and condemn injustice in clear and forceful language. But personal abuse weakens the argument, diminishes the profession and distracts attention from the injustice being challenged.

Equally, no judge should deliver a judgment that gives reasonable grounds for the perception that justice has been surrendered to political loyalty, personal interest or outside influence. The judicial oath demands independence, impartiality, integrity and fidelity to the law. These obligations must be evident in the reasoning and conduct of every judicial proceeding. The proposition that judges should avoid judgments that provoke insults must, however, be properly understood. A judge cannot guarantee that a disappointed litigant or counsel will respond responsibly. An unpopular judgment may be entirely just. The ethical demand is that judges deliver decisions supported by the law and the evidence, reached after a fair hearing, and accompanied by reasons that can withstand honest scrutiny.

Judicial error or misconduct does not excuse abuse; neither does abusive criticism erase legitimate questions about a judgment. The Nigerian Bar Association must hold these scales evenly. It must defend judges against intimidation and personal attacks while demanding accountability where credible evidence raises concerns about judicial conduct. Its defence of judicial independence must never become an attempt to place judicial decisions beyond robust criticism. Likewise, its insistence on professional discipline must never become a means of silencing lawyers who courageously identify injustice.

But the NBA must first demonstrate the standards it demands of others. Its elections, leadership selection, disciplinary processes and administration must reflect fairness, transparency and respect for the profession’s ethical obligations. An association cannot credibly preach integrity while tolerating practices that undermine integrity in the emergence of its own leaders. Where an association desecrates ethical standards in producing its leadership, it forfeits the moral authority to lecture others on those standards. That failure does not extinguish any lawyer’s professional obligations. It does, however, make the association’s demands appear selective and its disciplinary interventions vulnerable to accusations of hypocrisy.

Leadership must therefore welcome scrutiny, answer legitimate complaints and correct established wrongs. Calls for unity cannot substitute for accountability, and appeals to institutional dignity cannot justify concealing misconduct. The profession needs lawyers who speak with courage and restraint, judges who decide with independence and integrity, and an NBA whose conduct gives weight to its words. Respect for the courts and accountability within the courts are complementary duties. The NBA earns public confidence when it applies the same ethical measure to advocates, judicial officers and its own leadership—without fear, favour or partisan calculation.

You may also like

Leave a Comment

Online Media Published By

Precise Post Online Media Ltd (RC 7570339)

We are team of competent journalists, crafting compelling data-driven stories; shedding light on global news with precision and authority.

Precise Post @2024 – All Right Reserved. Designed and Developed by ObserverNG