Those familiar with South East terrain must have been jolted when the leadership of cattle breeders alleged the rustling of 300 cows and kidnap of 10 herders in the Ogbaru local government area of Anambra state.
The story re-enacted sad memories of the Chibok, Kankara and Kagara incidents where hundreds of students were abducted from their hostels and hurled into thick forests without any trace? The only difference being cows were more involved than humans. Could this be possible in that region given its terrain?
Even if it was possible to kidnap 10 herders and keep them out of public view, it appeared a remote possibility that 300 cows could just disappear in such environment without being traced in few hours.
Such was the feeling when South East Chairman of Miyetti Allah Cattle Breeders Association of Nigeria MACBAN, Gidado Siddiki alleged the abduction of 10 herders and rustling of 300 cows by gunmen. He had also alleged the gunmen established contacts demanding N4million ransom and one gun from the families of the victims.
But Anambra state police command in a statement, “Update on the alleged gunmen attack on herders in Anambra state, kidnap of 10 and rustling of 300 cows”, said “on April 24, 2022 some of the victims were seen in the bush unharmed while one of the victims is still missing”. They also discovered some of the livestock in the bush even as they are intensifying efforts to locate the herder and livestock still missing. The police promised further update on the matter.
But as the update was being awaited, Chairman of the Ogbaru local government area, Arinzechukwu Awogu faulted the kidnap report when he said no herder was kidnapped neither were cows rustled in the area.
The council boss described such reports as misleading even as he admitted there was a misunderstanding between farmers and herders which made the herders to flee the area for safety only to return to recover their cows when calm returned. Awogu who said he was personally involved with the leadership of MACBAN in returning normalcy to the area wondered why a case of abduction and cattle rustling would be peddled by Siddiki.
One may have ignored this story given that cattle rustling and kidnapping have become a regular occurrence in this country for which the law enforcement agencies are yet to find an appropriate handle. But that would amount to naivety of the most extreme hue.
Not with the intervention of the Ogbaru council chairman repudiating claims of the abduction and rustling. Not also with the tepid explanations offered by the police on the incident. There are weighty issues in the accounts of Siddiki and the police that should be interrogated further especially in view of the new angle offered by Awogu.
He did not only fault the kidnap and rustling allegation but also revealed the efforts he made with some MACBAN leaders to resolve the disagreement such that, by 11.30pm on the fateful day calm had been restored as all the cows rejoined their herders.
And since he spoke nothing has come either from MACBAN or the police to the contrary. It is also instructive the police said they saw the herders and some of the cows on the 24th of April, a day after the incident unharmed.
There are issues thrown up by the police account and the allegation by MACBAN that can only be ignored at a great risk especially given the nature of the allegation in contention. Police account of the incident appeared to have created more doubts than it set out to resolve. The disagreement took place on Saturday and resolved that same day. The police saw some of the victims and cows in the bush on Sunday unharmed. One herder was missing.
In a grave allegation of this nature, one had expected the police to have come clear on the number of herders they saw in the bush, their conditions and that of the cows. They should have come clear on whether it was a case of kidnapping and cattle rustling as alleged but they preferred to prevaricate.
The public deserves to know whether the bush the herders and cows were located by the police was the exact place of the disagreement or the dens of the alleged kidnappers. They should have come clear on whether the evidence they saw bore semblance with the allegations peddled by MACBAN or the account of the Ogbaru council boss. Surprisingly, they left those aspects of their investigation hanging.
But a cursory view of the title of police statement spoke of “alleged gunmen attack on herders…” My reading of this is that the police did not believe the allegation of an attack, kidnap and cattle rustling, Knowing that institution for what it is, they would not have had any difficulty reporting such if there was evidence to that effect.
Even then, the report that they saw the herders and the cows in the bush except one missing herder does not confer the kind of fatality the allegation of Siddiki conveyed. Neither did we see any evidence of the demand of N4million ransom and one gun each from the alleged victims.
So from where did the MACBAN leadership get the story of the money and gun ransom? And how come MACBAN went ahead to raise such an alarm when its leadership was involved in the resolution of the disagreement? How come?
These searing posers are at the center of the feeling that there is more to the MACBAN conduct than ordinarily meets the eyes. Not unexpectedly, this has given rise to speculations that the allegation could be a subterfuge for an impending attack on the community by killer herdsmen. Nobody should dismiss this dimension. Not with experiences in parts of the country.
It was good the police and the military swung into quick action in a bid to rescue the cows and the herders. Had this dexterity and quick response been demonstrated in protecting innocent citizens from attacks by killer herdsmen/bandits, that phenomenon would have by now been history. Security agencies should sustain this momentum to put a lie to insinuations that they responded the way they did because cows and herders were involved.
Category:
Opinion
By Prince MacDonald Enwere
According to Elie Wiesel, the foremost American-Jewish writer who survived the Holocaust “the glorious masterpiece of a leader is to live for others”.
In every ramifications, Onyeagucha has manifested the above assertion. He has dedicated a greater part of his life in fighting for the welfare of the poor, less privileged and the oppressed. He has been standing as a great defender of the cause of human freedom and unfettered liberty against the decomposing sore of sociopolitical insolence and ineptitude in our society. He has been defending the cause of social justice, equity and fairness.
The fight for human rights and Justice has remained his sole preoccupation. In the cause of fighting for the rights of the downtrodden, he has been abused, accused , humiliated , detained but he has remained unrelented and uncompromised.
From the Disabled whom Onyeagucha has defended their welfare, to the weak, the oppressed, the helpless, the hopeless and the powerless whose cause he has been defending, Onyeagucha has remained undaunted even in the midst of threat and intimidation.
Let’s Support Onyeagucha for Senate. He shall remain the voice of the voiceless, mouthpiece of the oppressed and defender of the downtrodden.
Bukola Saraki is one of the strongest contenders for PDP’s presidential nomination. On paper, his identity agnosticism (i.e., his capacity to be simultaneously a northerner and a southerner) is a great selling point, but he is, in reality, the most treacherous reprobate the party would have the misfortune to present.
As a Kwaran I feel a moral obligation to warn the nation about what kind of person Saraki is outside his cunningly packaged media image.
Saraki is an arrogant, corrupt, unfeeling wretch who, as a governor (and later a “governor general”), hardly paid workers’ salaries but who expended enormous resources to unleash sponsored media fury on workers who dared to tell the world that they were owed salaries.

People who have followed me on Facebook since 2015 will remember that in October 2015, I publicized the plight of the lecturers in Kwara State’s colleges of education who hadn’t been paid salaries for months and who, before the complete stoppage of their salaries, had endured making do with only 70 percent of their salaries for several months.
I followed up the status update with a full-length column in the Daily Trust titled “Who Will Save Kwara COE Lecturers from Saraki’s Deadly Grip?”
In the column, I wrote: “Senate President Bukola Saraki is called Kwara State’s ‘Governor- General’ for a reason: He is, for all practical purposes, the state’s de facto governor, and Governor Abdulfatah Ahmed is merely his impotent, obsequious caretaker. Ahmed must dutifully take orders from Saraki or risk losing his cushy surrogate governorship. This isn’t a flippant, ill-natured putdown of Governor Ahmed, who seems like a nice person; it’s an uncomfortable truth that many Kwarans know only too well.
“So, when I ask who will save lecturers in Kwara State’s colleges of education from death and starvation because they haven’t been paid salaries for six or seven months now, I am not barking up the wrong tree. Saraki is the main character in the movie of Kwara politics. Nothing happens there without his imprimatur.”
While Saraki and Ahmed sponsored infantile media attacks against me because of this, I did a Facebook fundraiser for the lecturers. One Dr. Nura Alkali kickstarted the fundraiser with a N200,000 donation. Several others followed.
The money I helped raise gave the lecturers some reprieve, and the publicity the gesture generated at the time shamed Saraki and his flunkey into paying the lecturers’ salaries.
But that was after many lecturers had died from starvation, after some of them had lost their children during childbirth because they couldn’t pay hospital bills, and after many of them had suffered the humiliation of not being able to send their children to school.
This was also the story of Saraki’s tenure as a two-term governor. Salaries and pensions were never guaranteed.
Memories of Saraki’s 16-year reign of terror for workers are still so enduringly traumatizing that when I wrote a critical article against Governor Abdulrahman Abdulrazaq sometime ago (I called him a “third-rate governor”), my paternal uncle, who’s a retiree, called to tell me that my critical opinions of the governor won’t resonate with workers or retirees because the governor had never owed salaries or pensions since he has been in power, which he said was a comforting departure from Saraki’s and Ahmed’s tenures.
Imagine the depth of despair and misery people must have experienced in the past for them to celebrate a governor just because he pays salaries, which is their just and legal entitlement.
In Nigeria, federal civil servants have historically been insulated from the terror of unpaid salaries. A President Saraki would ensure that even that little luxury disappears. He is unfathomably greedy and callous.
He is also insufferably egotistical and condescending to people and groups that his sterile mind tells him are beneath him. In my March 9, 2019, column titled “Why the Saraki Political Dynasty Collapsed,” I shared an anecdote that illustrates this attitude.
I wrote: “One of my townsmen who was a professor here in the United States and who returned home to ‘give back to the community’ a few years ago shared with me an experience he had with Saraki that captures Saraki’s imperiousness.
“He said Saraki asked to meet with elders of the Baruten community in Kwara State, which included the area’s four emirs, over a contentious issue regarding political representation. In light of his age, education, and exposure, the professor was prevailed upon to be a part of the delegation. He said the delegation arrived at the venue of the meeting on time, but that Saraki didn’t show up until several hours later.
“When he arrived, he didn’t apologize for his lateness, didn’t establish eye contact with anyone in the delegation, and proceeded to tongue-lash every one of them in the most humiliating manner because he was miffed that they had the impudence to oppose his political choice for the area. Then he stormed out in a huff. The professor said many old men in the group felt so humiliated and so crushed that they literally wept.”
That’s Bukola Saraki. He is a presidential disaster in waiting.
The only thing he is good at is paying people to propagandize for him, to manage the minds of people through artful traditional and social media manipulation to see him as someone he is not. Of course, he’s also good at paying headless troll farms to attack his opponents and critics.
After Buhari, is that the kind of person you want as president?
Bukola Saraki manipulated “northern elders” led by Professor Ango Abdullahi to simultaneously endorse him AND Bauchi State governor Bala Mohammed as the North’s “consensus candidates” for PDP’s presidential primaries.
But by what woolly arithmetic logic do two distinct people emerge as the “consensus candidates” of one region?
Well, Abdullahi reportedly said Saraki and Mohammed were “required to make further concessions so that in the end, one of them would be presented as the consensus candidate.” 😂How?
Of course, other PDP candidates have dismissed the “northern consensus” exercise as an immature political flimflam.
The clearest indication that the consensus circus was perpetrated by Saraki (with Bala Mohammed as one of the supporting cast) emerged from what Ango Abdullahi said about the “third phase” in the “zonal assessment” of the PDP candidates from the North.
He said the North-Central has not had an opportunity to present a candidate for election in the PDP since 1999 but stopped short of saying Saraki should therefore be the region’s consensus candidate.
It’s true, of course, that the North-Central hasn’t produced a president since 1999. It’s also valid to make the case that in the interest of representational justice in the North, the Northcentral should be favored to produce PDP’s candidate.
(For the record, my own personal preference, about which I’ve already written, is for the next president to come from the South-east, which has also not produced a president since 1999, in the interest of national unity).
But Saraki himself doesn’t believe in the sort of representational justice he wants to benefit from at the national level.
Kwara PDP zoned its governorship ticket to Kwara North (which consists of the Baatonu people of Baruten, the Bokobaru people of Kaiama, and the Nupe people of Edu and Patigi) in recognition of the political and symbolic marginality of the area in the state.
Of the three ethnic groups that make up Kwara North, only the Baatonu and Bokobaru people (who used to belong to what was called Western Borgu in the old Kwara State and who’re ethnic, cultural, and historical cousins) have never produced a governor.
The Nupe had Shaaba Lafiagi in the stillborn Third Republic, and most of them in PDP have conceded that, in the interest of symbolic unity, former Western Borgu (i.e., Baruten and Kaiama) should have the privilege to present the party’s next candidate.
But what did Saraki do? He arbitrarily and unilaterally decided that PDP’s governorship ticket should again go to Nupe people for no other reason than that he has a slavishly dutiful stooge from the place that he wants to puppeteer like he did former Governor Abdulfatah Ahmed who was a governor only in name.
Because of Saraki’s egocentric shortsightedness, PDP is now all but certain to lose the next governorship election in Kwara State even though Kwara APC is at its most vulnerable state since 2019 in light of its enduringly enervating internal turmoil, which pits Gov. Abdulrahman Abdulrazak’s camp against Lai Mohammed’s in an intense battle of supremacy.
How can a self-conceited, thoughtless, and narcissistic political bully like Saraki who has shown a chilly disdain for fairness in the representational politics of his own state expect to benefit from the same ideal at the national level?
Most importantly, though, why does Saraki need “consensus” to emerge as PDP presidential candidate? Why is he in dread of actual democratic contest against other contenders in a primary election?
I think it’s because he realizes that his political star has dimmed irretrievably in both Kwara State and nationally, so he wants to get his political desires through dishonest shortcuts.
For years, he’d ridden on the coattails of his late dad, who was a way better politician than he is, but the coattails are now threadbare and past their sell-by date.
Chido Nwakanma uses Earth Day today to reflect on Amuche Nnabueze, the artist that combines art and waste management
As the global community marks Earth Day, my mind goes to a woman with a passionate commitment to the sustainability of the environment. Amuche Ngwu Nnabueze deploys her art to her concern for the sustainability of the domain. She pursued this concern to earn a PhD in Fine and Applied Arts at the University of Nigeria, Nsukka.
Dr Amuche Nnabueze is a fine artist who now also teaches the subject at her alma mater.Her work seeks to improve solid waste disposal, handling and management in Nigeria, starting from Nsukka. It is also to curtail indiscriminate waste disposal using creative processes in South-Eastern Nigeria. Ultimately, she applies the creative arts and crafts approach to reducing indiscriminate waste handling.
Dr Amuche Nnabueze has been concerned with environmental issues for 20 years. I met her in Port Harcourt, where she worked with GTZ as a graphic artist. She then moved to UNN, still serving as a Graphic Artist with administrative responsibilities in an academic environment. After her PhD, she converted to the academic faculty. She is a designer and web developer.Her passion, however, is in the environment. That passion birthed Sculpted Basket Project, the initiative through which she documents her work and reaches out to society.
Sculpted BasketArt meets the environmental movement in Sculpted Basket. Amuche teaches and designs crafts projects aimed at remediating the environment. She uses “artistic and creative processes to create and raise awareness about the adverse effects of indiscriminate waste disposal.
“I reach out to educational and municipal policymakers one-on-one and the masses through social media. I teach waste separation starting from the point of generation (PoG) using locally made baskets.”
She also “upcycle and teach upcycle of non-decomposing solid wastes like paper, plastics, clothes, and plastic bottles to school children and young people where they learn how to use these waste materials instead of throwing them out indiscriminately.
“Through these activities, I create networking opportunities between solid waste generators, users, waste workers and managers to understand the process from different perspectives.”
Mrs Nnabueze imagines art beyond the visual appeal. She is now a noted campaigner and member of the global sustainable environment movement and was in Glasgow, Scotland, 2021, for the convention on sustainability.
She teaches sculpture, cultural and creative arts. She is a member of Parents For Future Nigeria and is actively involved in expanding PFF in Nigeria and as an organiser in Parents For Future Global.
She also pioneered the Sculpted Basket Project (SBP), which uses art to educate people about environmental concepts and sustainable lifestyles.She recalls, “During my undergraduate years, I consistently studied the impact human activities made on the urban area against the quiet and green rural areas. I initiated the Sculpted Basket Project in 2007 after gaining an MFA from Nsukka Art School, working on the project “Utilising Urban Wastes As Media For Sculpture”. My major project was revamping a quadrangle located in the faculty from a waste green site to a sit-out garden using non-decomposing throw-aways. In 2007, the Sculpted Basket Project conducted a basket-making workshop where we raised awareness.”
Sculpted Basket? Hear Dr Nnabueze: “Ikunye mmiri na nkata, “pouring water in a basket”, is an adage in Igbo which refers to making a futile effort. The concept of the Sculpted Basket Project is to use that challenge to achieve something tangible. To patch up baskets so that they can contain water is a literary interpretation of what it set out to do. The enormity of work needed to achieve a fair society in our impoverished environment is a driving force here. My visual concept of baskets contains a problem-solving unit capable of creating multiple impacts in a society with multiple problems.”
Amuche Nnabueze, MFA, converted her passion into a doctoral dissertation. Her work was on “The Utilisation of Urban Solid Wastes for artistic purposes as a tool in environmental management in Nsukka Urban Area”.
What public problem does she seek to solve? Improper waste disposal and management. “There are parastatals of the state government tasked with waste management, yet there is a huge solid waste management problem. Only about 40% of the generated solid wastes in cities find their way to designated places for collection. Only 40% are properly collected due to poor or lack of requisite equipment and staff to meet the ever-growing demand on the municipal facility, and users dump them on open dumpsites. These wastes are uncollected and may stay longer before they start rotting and constituting health and environmental problems. Sometimes the heap may be left to grow into busy street roads.
However, we can reduce these problems if these wastes are properly handled from the generation point by separating wastes and handling them according to type.”
Post-Glasgow, Amuche continues to pursue one of the goals of her PhD project to improve the primary school Cultural and Creative Arts curriculum to incorporate teaching about recycling and environmental management. She will reach out directly to schools and the local and state governments.
“The Sculpted Basket Project will need to network between schools to create reliable data ranging from location to Creative Arts schedule in their timetables. It needs to develop teaching aids. A mobile creative workstation (a mobile studio) will be essential since most schools are not adequately equipped for teaching and learning arts. This mobile workstation will need a desktop publishing capacity and worktables with various tools. Outcomes from this phase will continue to contribute to establishing an arts and crafts centre from which the Sculpted Basket Project can engage other felt needs in society”.
Editor’s Note
You can check Dr Amuche Nnabueze’s craft and journey on these sites.www.tearfund.org/tilz/footsteps_75/local_environemnt_local_crafts; www.sculptedbaskets.blogspot.com; Globalcrit.tumblr.com; www.unn.edu.ng; www.ccalagos.org; or artspeakafrica.blogspot.com; globalcrtiticlinic.wordpress.com; and books.google.com.ng/books/ What we want is Free, Second edition: Critical Exchanges in Recent Art edited by Ted Purves, Shane Aslan Selzer.
Osinbajo, RCCG, Pentecostalism, Corruption, And State Capture By Farooq Kperogi
by Edit
written by Edit
If you want to understand the issues I have been highlighting about Osinbajo’s attempts at RCCG state capture, read this insightful Nov. 20, 2019, interview Democracy in Africa had with Prof. Ebenezer Obadare, one of the most respected authorities on Pentecostalism . It’ll blow your mind:
Is Pentecostalism appropriating state power in Nigeria? Ebenezer Obadare, author of Pentecostal Republic: Religion and the Struggle for State Power in Nigeria responds to this and other questions from our editors.
Q: The title of your book, Pentecostal Republic: Religion and the Struggle for State Power in Nigeria, suggests a dominance of the Pentecostal movement over politics and governance in Nigeria, is that the case?
A: I believe so. In fact, I would go out on a limb and say that this dominance is by no means restricted to the mutually related spheres of politics and governance. What we observe over the course of the Nigerian Fourth Republic (1999- ) is the creeping pentecostalization of every facet of social life in Nigeria, including culture, entertainment, higher education, the economy and, based on recent reports on the use of “spiritual intelligence” by the Nigerian army’s top echelons, even military operations. No perceptive student of the Nigerian society would argue this dominance. Nor is the ubiquity noted in the Nigerian case limited to the country alone. Literature on religious movements in Ghana, Zambia, South Africa, Zimbabwe, to name a few key African countries, more or less takes the pervasiveness of Pentecostalism for granted.
Q: What gave rise to the ‘triumph of Christianity’ in Nigerian politics?
A: It seems to me that the triumph of Christianity (properly speaking, its contemporary ascendance, since the ‘triumph’ we are talking about is by no means definitive or irreversible) is bound up with the success of an exuberant form of Christianity worldwide. Within Nigeria, it is shown by a ‘power shift’ that saw a candidate from the South West step into the presidential saddle in 1999. The position I take in the book is that the political success of the South West was at the same time a moment of success for Christianity, since the pulpit was one of the major battlegrounds for the campaign for the reversal of the annulment of the June 12 1993 election. The role of the church as one of the most vocal voices within an implacable civil society that fought the military to a standstill has been acknowledged in many academic analyses. What is often overlooked, however, and a shift that my book calls attention to, is that, while it was the mainstream church (most prominently the Catholic Church) that joined in the campaign to overturn the June 12 annulment, it was Pentecostalism that stepped forward to be garlanded after victory had been won, having moved into pole position as the dominant expression of Christianity (in the country, if not elsewhere in Africa and globally) in the last decade of the 20th century.
As a result, while the Yoruba electorate embraced Olusegun Obasanjo (1999- 2007) as a co-ethnic and symbolic ‘compensation’ for the theft of June 12 and the death in detention of M.K.O. Abiola; and Christians in general embraced him as divine answer to their prayers for a Christian president, Pentecostals (touting the story of his being ‘Born Again’ in prison) claimed him as one of their own. Long story short: the ‘triumph of Christianity’ in Nigeria was fashioned in June 12’s overcoat, belonging as it is to the unforeseeable chain of events unleashed by the abrogation of the June 12 1993 election.
Q: One of your main arguments is that Pentecostalism became more influential with the emergence of democracy in Nigeria, why is that so? Is there a particular relationship between Pentecostalism and democracy in Nigeria?
A: One of the driving arguments in Pentecostal Republic is that the emergence of democracy in Nigeria is tied up with the ascendance (different from emergence, which dates to an earlier period) of Pentecostalism. The subsidiary argument is that we cannot fully grasp democratic practice in Nigeria since 1999 without a corresponding attention to the power and influence of Pentecostalism. Of the four presidents that the country has had since 1999, two [Olusegun Obasanjo and Goodluck Jonathan (2010- 2015)] were card-carrying Pentecostals, who needed no invitation to drape state occasions and ceremonies with the insignia and apparels of the church. The current Vice President, Yemi Osinbajo is a Pentecostal pastor and member of the Redeemed Christian Church of God (RCCG), easily the most politically influential church in Nigeria today. The influence of Pentecostalism on Nigerian democracy manifests in many other ways, the most profound of which is the ascendance of a mentality that renders moot any kind of distinction between fact and fantasy.
Nigerian Pentecostalism is, on balance, a reactionary and anti-intellectual force with a real capacity to undo the very idea of critical deliberation without which a democracy is bound to atrophy.
Q: From reading your book, it appears there is a struggle for influence between Christian conservatives and Pentecostals, how is the struggle impacting politics in the country?
A: There is definitely a struggle for influence between “Christian conservatives” (broadly speaking mainline Christians who resent the dominance and perceived recklessness of Pentecostalism and advocate a return to the “old” Christianity) and Pentecostals. No less real is the struggle within Pentecostalism itself, between Pentecostals who are uncomfortable with its romance with politics and accommodation of popular culture, and others who do not necessarily see anything wrong with Pentecostal praxes. On current evidence, the “conservatives” do not seem to have had any real impact, as the version of Pentecostalism that has managed to assert itself in the political sphere, the exuberant one, is the dominant one.
Q: Generally, international media reports seem to suggest that Muslims and Boko Haram have more political influence in Nigeria, what are your thoughts on that?
A: It would be interesting to know how such reports measure “political influence”. Boko Haram can be easily dismissed since it is an Islamist insurgent group that seems to have come into existence, ab initio, because its members, among other grievances, felt politically marginalized. As things stand, it is because Boko Haram has no political influence (not to be confused with causing political agitation) that its members continue to attack state targets and ordinary civilians, Muslim and Christian. As for Muslim political influence, there is a plausible argument to be made. For instance, it may be pointed out that the incumbent president, Muhammadu Buhari, is a Muslim, one who has been accused of loading the dice of political appointments in favor of the predominantly Muslim North. But that observation, credible as it sounds, undercounts the extent to which Buhari, whose deputy is a Pentecostal pastor, relies on the continued support of powerful Pentecostal pastors, and the role of Pentecostalism in the shaping of political choices by state officials at all levels.
Q: In most African countries, politicians seek support from Pentecostal leaders, who have power to instruct their followers to support certain politicians, in your book you seem to suggest that it is Pentecostal leaders seeking more influence through politicians, what exactly do the Pentecostal leaders want?
A: I think it is a bit of both. While politicians ingratiate themselves with Pentecostal leaders, seeing in them the most direct routes to their (i.e. pastors’) vast congregations; at the same time, pastors, no doubt conscious of the fact that the muzzle of arbitrary political power can always be turned against them, cozy up to politicians. Which is why Pentecostal leaders (not all of them, to be sure) want more. They desire the prestige, paraphernalia, and dare I say, unaccountability, of political office, which is why many of them already behave like politicians. For instance, having orbited power for so long, and having failed once as a vice-presidential candidate, Pastor Tunde Bakare of the Lagos-based Latter Rain Ministries recently declared his intention to run for the presidency in 2023.
Q: If Nigeria is a ‘Pentecostal Republic’ as you suggest, why has corruption and abuse of power continued?
A: Your question assumes that Pentecostalism and corruption are mutually contradictory. That is not what the evidence shows. What the data from Nigeria and other African countries seem to suggest is that Pentecostalism has very little to do with ethics. For one thing, Pentecostal churches themselves are hotbeds of corruption. For another, Pentecostal leaders are regularly implicated in the abuse of power. For example, many of the high profile cases of sexual harassment in Nigeria and other African countries have involved Pentecostal pastors. Finally, Pentecostal advocacy of the Prosperity Gospel (according to which the how of wealth acquisition is irrelevant) essentially boils down to a justification of ill-gotten wealth. The conclusion is difficult to avoid that Pentecostalism in Nigeria is both a vehicle and driver of corruption.
Q: How do you see the future of relations between different religions and politics in Nigeria?
A: It is difficult to tell, since both religion and politics are dynamic phenomena, no more so than in their interrelation. One cannot say in what ways the existing religious formation will change, whether as a response to internal or external, local or foreign stimuli. Nor can we confidently predict the trajectory of politics. Nevertheless, it seems certain that, for the foreseeable future, Pentecostalism will continue to exercise an outsize influence on Nigerian politics, and that Pentecostal influence, were it to continue at the same pace, and given the perennial struggle for political hegemony in the country, would trigger a reaction from Muslims. No matter the nature of that reaction, and especially if it is one of imitation and appropriation as we’ve seen in Western Nigeria, the student of religion and politics in Nigeria can look forward to an interesting future.
Ebenezer Obadare is Professor of Sociology at the University of Kansas, USA, and Fellow of the Institute of Theology, University of South Africa.
In the song ‘Ekwueme’, Osinachi calls The Almighty by many names. In truth, they are all deeply moving. But the one that struck me the first time I listened was the name, ‘Ga Ga N’Ogwu’. He who tramples on thorns. Ga Ga N’Ogwu. It struck me because, up till that moment, I had only ever heard that phrase in my hometown, Isuochi. You see? When I was a child, there was a masquerade by that name. Yes. In the masquerade culture of the time, Ga Ga N’Ogwu was one, and a powerful praise name too. But I thought it a coincidence. Till I learned, after her death, that Osinachi – like me – was from Isuochi.
Because, in truth, it is impossible to separate the artist from her art. I tell you. It is not possible to examine a person’s art and not find traces of them. Always, we leave clues. Of who we are, where we come from, what we are going through, how we cope. But if you don’t know our story you will not see the clues. Yes. Now we know, that when a powerful gospel singer from a broken and battered home clutches the microphone, and, with an unnerving tremor in her voice, refers to God as, ‘Anya n’elete onye emejoro n’uwa’ – He who watches over those this world is treating badly – it is a cry for help.
I wish she knew she could have reached out, not just up, for help. You can reach out, not just up, for help. I know that many times ‘How are you?’ is said in mindless courtesy. But sometimes, in answer to your prayer, God sends someone to you who will ask ‘How are you?’ in true love. For not all miracles are preceded by lightning. Some miracles come with the soft beeping of your phone. A friend, a brother, a sister, a mother, reaching out in the middle of the night to ask, ‘Nne, o di kwo mma?’ Will it not be sad to die and get to Heaven, to see God and begin to quarrel Him for not coming through for you, only for Him to pull up that memory, to show you that text – Nne, o di kwo mma? – and say, very sadly, ‘That was me’…Would this not be sad?
Still, in her worship – in those fleeting minutes when she lost herself in worship – I believe Osinachi knew peace. For her sister tells the painful story of how, after one of the many episodes of abuse, Osinachi clutched her chest in her husband’s presence and cried out, ‘Peter, i na gbawa mu obi!’ Peter, you are breaking my heart… And there on stage, in the presence of the thousands watching her live, and the millions who have watched her since, she cried out, at the tail end of her iconic song, she said, ‘I medawo mu obi, Chukwu oma…’ Dear Lord, you have brought comfort to my aching heart… Before descending back into the waiting arms of her trauma. Yes. This is how personal performance can be. I tell you. If the art moves you deeply it is only because it has moved its maker…deeply.
True. Osinachi, the thorn-bush you spent your marital life trudging through tore your skin to pieces. You bled, and bled, and bled to death. For Ga Ga N’Ogwu is not the spirit for abusive marriages. No. For no matter how much anointing you return with from the presence of God, to shield and protect you, the abuser’s slap will pierce straight to the bone. Yes. It is that other name you called the Lord – Agu batara ohia mgbada awara oso – that is the one for abusive marriages. That at the sight of the leopard, the deer flees for dear life. I know. We all fancy ourselves the lion, forgetting Jesus was half-lamb. I tell you, at the manifestation of abuse, children of God, be the deer and get out of there. For there will be no couples standing before God on Judgement Day. No. On that day, we stand alone.
Yes. Osinachi, nwanne m, you? You will live on in that voice that moved multitudes to tears. This is the immortality the creator of enduring art will always enjoy. That in the grip of trouble bigger than us we will remember you called God ‘Oloro ihe loro ihe loro enyi’ – the One who swallowed that which swallowed that which swallowed an elephant. And when things happen that confound us, we will remember you called God ‘Amama masiri amasi’ – the all-wise One who cannot be confounded. And when we are confronted with situations that require tough choices, like to stay in an abusive relationship – for fear of what people will say, of what we will lose, of how we will start over – to stay in such a relationship, or to walk away, we will remember you called God, ‘Oke mmanwu n’eti onwe ya’… Yes. The Great Masquerade who is not afraid to walk alone… This is the truth.
Osinachi, nwanyi oma, nwelete, la l’udo.
THE PUBLIC SPHERE with Chido Nwakanma
Umuahia and Aba are the two significant cities in Abia State. While Umuahia is the state capital, Aba is the torchbearer for commerce and entrepreneurship. They both appeal for different reasons.
I like to check out hotels in the cities I visit for what they say about the places. Other factors come into play to determine where you lodge in a town. During my first visit to New York for the International Association of Business Communicators (IABC) world conference, I stayed in Hotel Edison, one block away from Times Square, Manhattan. It was to enable me to check out the city’s attractions. The cost was also a factor in preferring Hotel Edison to the Hilton Manhattan, the host hotel.
Hospitality experts list ten must-haves of good hotels. They include cleanliness, adequate safety/security, Internet, comfortable beds, and bathroom plumbing. Others are lighting, particularly in the rooms, aroma, simple and tasty food, and an excellent front desk for easy check-in and check-out.
Aba and Umuahia share a similar approach to hotel patronage. They flock to the newest place, the new kid on the block
Rixos Continental Resort shines and dazzles in Umuahia
In Umuahia, Rixos Continental Resort is the new belle. Occupancy is high, and rooms go off the rack quickly.
Rixos Continental Resort by CBN Junction off Bende Road, Umuahia 440324 is eye candy. Its modern building delights, and it offers standard facilities in the rooms. The standard room is, well, standard—the current offer of tea facilities in the room, decent plumbing, and many towels.
Its Blue Caribbean Swimming Pool is inviting. Then there is a poolside bar and an Irish garden on the other side and plenty of room for gathering near the pool and bar. There is an elevated space on the first floor above the bar. The ambience is salubrious.

Dum Hall is the conference facility of Rixos Hotel, and Rixos declares that it “affords you a unique opportunity to meet in style.”
The website of Rixos Continental Hotel announces a gym. It boasts that it is the only hotel in Umuahia with an elevator. Rixos is one of three trending hotels in Umuahia. The other two are Hotel Royal Damgrete and Golden Olives Hotel.
However, the average waiting time for meals we ordered at Rixos Continental was one and half hours. We experienced the same at Ibiza Resort Hotel, the comely new bride of Aba hotels.
Ibiza Hotel & Resort is the new bride of Aba hospitality
Ibiza is luxe and modern, sits on Okigwe Road and has become a significant attraction. Its architect converted a small space (for the scale of its ambition) into something elegant and appealing. The car park tells of the constricted space as vehicles jostle.

The rooms are well-aspected. Ibiza offers good free high-speed internet (WiFi), a swimming pool, a fitness centre and gym, a children’s activities space and a business centre.
The poolside Aba is a critical attraction in Ibiza. Customers gather here more than in the restaurant or bar. The offering is good with a barbecue stand to grill stuff.
Ibiza Hotel seems to have moved the crowd from Hotel Du Golf, Old GRA, Aba.
Hotel Du Golf radiates quality and timeless elegance
The exquisite Hotel Du Golf radiates quality and timeless elegance. The promoters built it in the best fashion.
Hotel Du Golf appeals despite the toll of age. It was the place to be a few years ago, near the Aba Golf Club and the Governor’s Lodge. We came in late to lodge and tested its claim to 24 hours service. I ordered snacks and coffee. Then I called laundry to do a quick turnaround with my clothes. Hotel Du Golf staff delivered on both counts.
Facilities include a standard swimming pool, a gym, a minimart and boutique, and spacious halls that the hotel describes as a “classic place for all events.” Meals are African cuisine and continental/oriental cuisine.

Abia Hotel should be better
Abia Hotel is one of the oldest hotels in the state. It started as the Catering Rest House of the colonial and immediate post-colonial days. There are two in Aba, but we stayed in the main one opposite the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints.
Binez Hotel, an old player in hospitality in Aba, won the concession to manage this hotel. They have not started. The less said about Abia Hotel, the better. I scribbled in my notebook that Abia Hotel is in a time warp. It is like stepping into the 1980s.
The rooms are big with substantial 6×6 beds. I changed from Room 207 to 203 because of the noisy wall unit air conditioner, an otherwise unclean room, a television without remote control (same as in the next room) and the lack of a writing table. Of course, it did not have WiFi.
Yet, Abia Hotel has extensive grounds for outdoor parties. There are chalets with suites or rooms that people rent for meetings and socials. It should have healthy patronage in this political season. Binez should activate its concession and make it work.
Quality speaks even after many years at Hotel Royal Damgrete
Twenty years later and with new solid competitors, Hotel Royal Damgrete can still claim its self-assigned moniker as the best hotel in Umuahia.
Quality speaks and lasts—Damgrete benefits from the excellent finishing of its exterior and interior many years later.
I was here first in 2000. It is still spick and span. The marble finishing has helped it age well without the disfigurement and loss of colour that often happens with similar facilities.

Each hotel defers to its environment. Hotel Royal Damgrete offers mainly local cuisine, from breakfast to dinner. It is just as well.
It is one of a few hotels in Abia State and the South-East to offer local delicacies such as ukazi with achara. They are niggardly with the achara, but they had it to serve.
On this visit, Ikeddy Isiguzo and I hosted the Umuahia chapel of the Correspondents Association to break bread and bond. It was an exciting evening.
The next day, April 8, I shared drinks with my schoolmates at the Federal School of Arts & Sciences, Aba (Class of 80-82). Our school no longer exists because Nigeria phased out A-Levels, but it exists in our hearts and minds with shared experiences.
On hand for the evening meeting were Joy Utah, Onyebuchi Nwoko aka Oncle, Chuks Onuoha and class captain Johnson Owanta. The Class of 80-82 plans a 40-year Reunion on 22 – 24 April 2022.
The service at Hotel Royal Damgrete is courteous. The staff are helpful. They are available and willing and do not disappear as in some other hotels.
The rooms are spacious and outfitted with the right mix of facilities. They now offer standard air-conditioning, desk, WiFi, and television with many channels. The bathroom is neat; it reflects its age with a bathtub and handheld shower. They would do better with more recent wash facilities and showers. And more than one towel, please!
Hotel Royal Damgrete offers reasonable grounds. There is a swimming pool, a lawn tennis court, and a gym. People sit out as we did poolside with a bar. Then there is a well-equipped gym.
I found some of the art furniture on the grounds alluring.
Hotel Royal Damgete on Factory Road, Umuahia, deserves many repeat visits and stays.
Hardware sans software and no tourism promotion
The hospitality industry in the South-East generally has shown great capacity in hardware. The hotels are often attractive physical specimens. Unfortunately, the service software is a significant drawback, with few exceptions.
Service. Service. Service.
The hotels and facilities in the two towns say that Abians are up-to-date and contemporary.
None of the hotels had any tourism promotion of any kind. No one in Umuahia offered guests, including on this trip many guests from the South West and South-South as well as renowned journalists and educators, any journey to tourism spots in Umuahia or Aba. The government’s tourism promotion agency should have at least information desks in the more prominent hotels. Such desks are standard in South Africa, Kenya, and even Ghana.
The hotels are vibrant with patronage. Do hotels reflect the economy, or are they bubble zones removed from the reality of the larger society? Big debate. However, the construction standards speak to the desirable.
About Hotels
The primary purpose of hotels is to provide travellers with shelter, food, refreshment, and similar services and goods, offering things furnished within households but unavailable to people on a journey away from home, says Encyclopedia.com
“Historically, hotels have also taken on many other functions, serving as business exchanges, sociability centres, public assembly and deliberation, decorative showcases, political headquarters, vacation spots, and permanent residences”, it adds.
Globally, hotels as industry and institutions transformed travel, creating new areas of activity while extending the influence of urban culture. Great hotels have contributed to the beautification of the landscape of their cities. They are also an index of real estate, construction standards and modelling other virtues.
Significantly, hotels speak to the living standards of a city. You can tell about the living index of a city by the quality and type of hotels within it. It may even be aspirational.
Nicon Noga Hilton Hotel opened to great acclamation in 1986 in Abuja for bearing the hopes and visions of a capital city in the making. It was huge, classy, and international standard. Yet, Abuja was a city in the making.
Have you booked your accommodation and tourist site for Easter 2023?
https://enugumetro.com/hotels-in-aba-and-umuahia/.
Three years ago, my mother-in-law sent me a video. It was of ‘Nara ekele’. That was the first time I heard Osinachi. She raised goose-bumps, and had my spirit beating against the prison bars of my own ribcage, asking to be let out. Ah! Then I listened to ‘Ekwueme’, and thought – Wow, what a voice. No, not the voice. The…tremor beneath the voice. As if, at a certain point, a door within her opens, and something deep – cannot quite be cloaked in words – emerges. I tell you, it is hard to listen unmoved. Yes. I wonder now. Was it the Holy Spirit that moved me so? Or was it the pain within her own spirit? Yes. For deep calls to deep. And divine essence and human trauma, I carry both within me too…
So, as an artist, I know. That we can bleed on stage – and weep on stage, and cry on stage, for help, for love, for understanding – and those watching us will only applaud. But this is not what I am here to say. What I am here to say is this. You see this marriage thing? Yes. It is a contract, yes, but not a contract for sale. No. You do not own me. To do with me what you will. No. See, you will never have that power. For I am a human spirt. And my first obligation is to find and fulfil the purpose for which I exist. Not to love you, or cook for you, or care for you, or sleep with you. It is to become, to the fullest extent possible, what God made me to be. My sister, that is your first obligation too. And a marriage that no longer respects this has become bondage.

For to love is to serve. It is to ask – how can I help you become? And to be loved is to be served. It is to be asked – how can I help you become? Yes. It is this exchange of service, between two people of equal value, that is marriage. Not blows, and self-centered demands. Not abuse, and a desire to control so strong you lash out violently every time I deviate from what you wish. Come, na who you be sef? See, I will not tolerate it, this abuse. To be slapped, or pushed, or punched, or kicked, or spoken to with words that strip me of my dignity, self-belief and sense of purpose. I tell you. For nothing – nothing! – the abuser offers pays back for what they take. Get out of there!
For divorce is not a dirty word. No. It is an acknowledgment that, at 25 (or whenever it was you entered into an abusive relationship), your eyes were not as clear as they are today. It is to know that ‘for better, for worse’ anticipates change, yes, but the sorts of changes we cannot anticipate, you know? Like cancer or dementia or the loss of a limb. Not intentional ones, like your spouse waking up one morning and deciding to maim, murder or de-humanize you. No. Divorce is recognizing that marriage – which does not exist in Heaven – cannot be a condition for making Heaven. That if it is truly two becoming one, then the one who reaches across to strangle the other has physically ripped that curtain in two. Which marriage again? That the same Jesus who asked you not to cast stones at a woman they said they caught in adultery, will not stand there glaring at you – as you run out of an abusive home – with a deep frown on his face. You see? That theology is contradictory. And the confusion is not in God. It is in the minds of those who teach this. That a godly woman is one who can take a punch in silence.
God forbid! It is the smuggling of culture – a culture in which marriage is seen as a sales agreement by which man purchases wife – into faith. You see? That the Word is used, not to set free, but to reinforce the bondage of women. I tell you, many things are worth dying for. Our faith, after all, is rooted in redemptive suffering. But an abusive marriage is not one of them. No. It is never faith that keeps the abused with the abuser. It is the fear of what we would all say if a famous gospel singer abandons (for that is how we will report it) her husband and children. You see? It is never faith that keeps the abused with the abuser. It is the false hope we peddle, in the guise of counselling, that enduring – without actively resisting – abuse will somehow lead to change. You see? It is never faith that keeps the abused with the abuser. It is the knowledge, at the back of her mind, that if she leaves, we will allow her to stay with us, maybe a few months, but after he comes begging, with some pastors in tow, we will gently coax her back…
Yes. For Osinachi Madu who put her trauma in her voice, and in her brokenness gave faith to so many. For her who could not defend herself. For her! Let us draw these lines in the sand and say it, as Christians, with our full chest – domestic violence is grounds for divorce. Full stop.
By Hon. Victor Afam Ogene
I can wager that at first mention, his name is not known within political circles. It sounds esoteric and so, would not elicit much interest, beyond the ‘Rich’ appellation attached to it.
But if anyone has heard about the name Belemaoil, chances are that given Nigeria’s oil propelled economy, the company, though hardly a household name, sure rings a bell.
Yet, the name, Tein Jack-Rich and Belemaoil share an affinity. They are consanguineous. One and the same; the former is the promoter of the latter. The big name behind the oil giant. By way of recapitulation, Jack-Rich is the President/Founder of Belemaoil Producing Limited, arguably the first indigenous oil exploration and production company in Nigeria to emerge from an oil producing community located deep in the heart of the Niger Delta: Kula in Akuku-Toru LGA of Rivers state.
Born on January 28, 1975, the Jack-Rich personae however does not revolve only around Belemaoil as the Operator of the NNPC/Belemaoil OML-55 Joint Venture. At 47, he is rather focussed on reengineering Nigeria and has therefore indicated interest in the 2023 presidential contest. His vehicle: The All Progressives Congress, APC.
Of the about half-a-dozen aspirants jostling for the APC presidential ticket, only Jack-Rich comes seemingly ready and well made, through what the famed novelist, the late Professor Chinua Achebe termed, “solid personal achievements.”
I wonder how many Nigerians have heard Jack-Rich speak. Perhaps, with the possible exception of Vice President Yemi Osinbajo, one can vouchsafe that no other aspirant, across party divide, can match Jack-Rich’s oratorical prowess.
Unarguably, he can hold his audience spellbound and mesmerize them with the sheer mellifluity of his own expressions, dissecting and deconstructing otherwise complex issues in very sensible and practical ways.
As a matter of fact, he possesses the added advantage of enunciating and canvassing policies and programmes that resonate with the mass of the society.
While one is compelled to say that the other aspirants either had their palm kernels cracked for them by benevolence or benefited over time from public funds as former/current public office holders, it’s not so for Jack-Rich.
From the relatively tender age of 10, the challenges of adulthood was inexplicably foisted on Jack-Rich. Having lost both parents at that tender age, he had to meander through a labyrinth of the most chronic level of penury, and deprivation.
Toiling night and day, through thick and thin, fishing in the cold, rumbling seas of the Niger Delta was, for the most part of Jack-Rich’s adolescent life, the only means of eking out a living for himself and his siblings.
Through unwavering perseverance and an abiding faith in God, a window of opportunity opened for Jack-Rich at the age of 21, in 1996, when a Louisiana, United States of America, USA-based oilfield firm, Dickson International, offered him employment.
Twelve years afterwards, through a combination of hard work and honesty, Jack-Rich founded J+G Global Gas & Oilfield Limited. Several other subsidiaries quickly followed, each providing specialised services in “oil and gas related fields such as pipeline works, oil field personnel supply, oil producing facilities upgrade, gas processing facilities installation and production operations profiling for oil flow optimization, both offshore, swamp and onshore for USA, UK, Norway, Singapore and Nigeria based international operators and service providers.”
Goaded by his philanthropic disposition, and a desire to give back to society, he established the Belema and the Jack-Rich Foundation, through which he awarded scholarships to thousands of students, many of whom have graduated from schools in Canada, Ghana, Ukraine, the USA, UK, Malaysia, Nigeria, North Cyprus, and the Philippines.
Notedly, he has extended same selfless support across Nigeria, with footprints of industrial type potable water for struggling communities in three locations in each of the about 12 states chosen by his Foundation across the six geo political zones.
The completed and ongoing projects are located in Bauchi, Borno, Gombe, Kano, Adamawa, Bayelsa, Katsina, Sokoto, Enugu, Osun, Ondo and Rivers.
A multidimensional strategic thinker, motivator and firm believer in a Greater Nigeria, Jack-Rich holds the view that Nigeria is the economic trigger required to set the African continent on the path of sustainable growth and development.
Whenever the question about his foray into the seemingly murky waters of politics arises, Jack-Rich appears to have a ready made answer: “I’m not the owner of the wealth brought into my care; it is to impact generations positively and to serve humanity for the good of all. Wealth stockpiled without placing it in motion to create more wealth is stagnant wealth capable of causing toxins. It is destructive and can be a curse to me if I fail to create wealth for others.”
Would members of the APC, nay Nigerians, offer Jack-Rich the opportunity to live up to his name: jack up the rich potentials of the country?
The answer is tucked in the womb of time. But for sure, someone with the necessary prerequisites and appropriate credential for the top job can be found in Jack-Rich.
•Hon. Ogene, a former member of Nigeria’s House of Representatives, is a chieftain of the All Progressives Congress, APC.
By Dr. Ezrel TABIOWO
Last week, Wednesday, to be precise, the Senate in plenary, considered a motion kicking against the tariff increase by MultiChoice Nigeria, a leading PayTV company operating in the country with business interests across Africa.
The chamber, in its resolutions, demanded a probe into the hike in tariff amid a call for the downward review of bouquet prices.
Accordingly, a seven-man ad-hoc panel was constituted by the Senate President, Dr. Ahmad Lawan, to investigate the circumstances surrounding the sudden price increment, particularly at a time when the country is faced with stifling economic realities.
The investigating panel, Chaired by the Deputy Whip of the Senate, Senator Aliyu Sabi Abdullahi, has six other lawmakers as members.
Senator Sabi Abdullahi, a versed and highly experienced legislator, is a veterinarian and researcher by profession, who also served as spokesman of the Eighth Senate.
The ad-hoc committee under his leadership was given a one-month deadline to submit its findings and recommendations in a report to be debated during plenary for adoption by the chamber.
Reactions Trailing Senate’s Action
Whilst a lot of Nigerians applaud the pro-people effort by the Senate to halt the plan by MultiChoice to effect tariff increase, one Opeyemi Maiyegun, authored what clearly was an article maliciously intended to denigrate and blackmail the upper chamber for its responsiveness.
He described the action by the Nigerian Senate in response to the hike in tariff by MultiChoice as a “faux concern for the masses”, and called on it to probe other issues of importance such as the Kaduna train attack. How ridiculous!
To be honest, the writer displayed a high level of ignorance concentrated in crass assumptions about the posture and accomplishments of the Ninth Assembly on matters of security, otherwise, how could he not know that the Senate had a day earlier, on Tuesday, March 29, 2022, debated the train attack by terrorists? What a way to goof!
I strongly believe there are a litany of questions begging for answers. Is he (Maiyegun) not aware of the numerous motions and point of orders raised by lawmakers at different times on the deteriorating security situation across the country? How does he explain the fact that he lacks knowledge of the robust and passion-driven contributions of lawmakers who had severally criticised the federal government and security agencies over their inability to tackle insecurity, but was able to follow the motion on tariff increment by MultiChoice?
Was he oblivious to the fact that the Senate in its resolutions at three different sittings in 2020 – January, July and December – requested the President to sack the Service Chiefs as a result of the lingering insecurity? Was he also not aware that it was the resolutions of the chamber on the Senator Kashim Shettima motion, considered on December 1, 2020, that prompted the eventual removal of the Service Chiefs seven weeks later on 26th January, 2021? How much more pro-people can a Parliament get!
What I can possibly infer from Maiyegun’s hypocrisy and lack of knowledge on these events is that not only is he not informed at all, he is, in fact, far from being the patriotic individual which he wants us to believe that he is.
How The Nigerian Market Sustains MultiChoice
It is no longer news that the Nigerian market spins the highest earnings for MultiChoice on the continent of Africa. This, apparently, seems to be a major reason behind the persistent clamour by the National Assembly and Nigerian subscribers for reduced prices on packages and the demand for Pay-As-You-View regime (PAYV) as mode of subscription as against same being Pre-Paid.
About six years ago in 2016, DStv said its total subscriber base in Africa was about 10.4 million across 50 states, with Nigeria alone having about 1.5 million subscribers. This, of course, excludes GOtv subscribers.
A report by Digital TV Research, a UK analysis firm, projected that by 2027, MultiChoice subscription base will double by hitting 20.8 million subscribers across its DStv and GOtv platforms in Africa. It is expected that DStv subscribers will double to 3 million in Nigeria alone, excluding GOtv subscribers.
The report further shows that Pay-Tv subscriptions in Africa which stood at 39 million as at 2021 will grow exponentially to 57 million by 2027. Therefore, MultiChoice alone would account for 36.8 percent (20.8m) of the total number of subscriptions in Africa.
In addition, out of the $6.46 (USD) billion projected revenues for Pay-Tv subscriptions in 2027, DStv will rake-in about $2.4 (USD) billion from Africa, with about 15 percent of the total amount which is a staggering figure coming from Nigeria alone.
Now, let us assume that the new increase by DStv which ranges between N450 and N550 for each subscriber is nothing to complain about, when the average amount of N500 is multiplied by 1.5 million users, which is the number of subscribers six years ago – and by the way isn’t the figure in 2022, it means DStv will generate an additional N750 million excluding the total revenue it makes on subscriptions every month depending on the package. For a year, that comes to N9 billion naira.
In my considered view, that is an outrageous amount to be raked by a non-Nigerian entity on a differential price increase alone. The news of this would be likened by Nigerians to a white collar heist orchestrated by MultiChoice under their very nose. Had Maiyegun restrained his itchy fingers and maintained décorum without getting biased with the Senate, perhaps, the lid of DStv’s pandora box may have been kept tightly shut, but no thanks to him. He may, however, wish to weigh his chances carefully in the future before attempting a similar endeavor.
The Nigerian People vs MultiChoice
Several entreaties by the National Assembly for MultiChoice to introduce the Pay-As-You-View (PAYV) subscription regime or implement a reduction to prices have always met a brick wall.
An attempt by the South African company to effect an increase to subscription rates in September 2020, was halted by the Federal Government when it explained that doing so would be “hostile to Nigerians who are currently going through harsh economic conditions” as a result of the coronavirus pandemic at the time.
The move by MultiChoice to effect a price change caused both chambers of the National Assembly to intervene promptly by calling for the Pay-As-You-View regime as it obtains in some African countries.
It wouldn’t be the first time that the National Assembly and Nigerian subscribers have made such demand. Both chambers had before 2019 requested the PayTV service provider to replace its Pre-Paid monthly service with PAYV.
Responding to the request on January 11, 2019, the Chief Customer Officer of MultiChoice, Martin Mabutho, in an interview he granted in Lagos, without any consideration to the demand of Nigerians, was emphatic and final in his response.
Mabutho stated categorically that the company would not operate the Pay-As-You-View subscription mode.
The reason he advanced was that the contract entered into with their suppliers was on a monthly basis, hence, there was no going back on same.
His exact words, “We are NOT going to introduce pay as you view system. Our contract with our suppliers is on month to month basis.”
“The issue of NOT introducing pay as you view remains. NOTHING will change it.
“We are NOT going to do it. Our contract with our suppliers are month to month basis. The channels do not belong to MultiChoice”, he added.
At another instance, the Chief Executive Officer of MultiChoice Nigeria, John Ugbe, while appearing before the House of Representatives Ad-hoc Committee investigating the non-implementation of the PAYG subscription model by satellite TV operators on October 13, 2020, explained that they do not have the technology to help them render the PAYG billing model as requested by most Nigerian subscribers.
According to him, the PAYG model being implemented by telcos is not compliant with satellite TV.
Unearthing Facts About MultiChoice’s Digital Satellite Subscription
In an attempt to unravel the claims made by the CEO of MultiChoice that the PAYG or PAYV is not complaint with satellite TV, I decided to read through the “Terms and conditions of subscription to MultiChoice’s digital satellite subscription broadcasting service for Commercial Use” found below:
https://www.multichoice.com/media/2136/dstv-subscription-terms-and-conditions-for-commercial-subscribers.pdf
Contrary to claims made by the CEO, MultiChoice, in fact, offers different services in the various countries where it operates.
The MultiChoice subscriber agreement on page 34, 1.3 attests to this: “MultiChoice cannot guarantee that the MultiChoice Service, or aspects thereof, in whole or in part, will be available at all places within a particular country or in every country in which MultiChoice provides the MultiChoice Service.”
It goes further to state that, “Equipment acquired or used in one country or in the Coverage Area of a particular satellite might not also be used to receive the MultiChoice Service, or aspects thereof, in another country or in the Coverage Area of another satellite.”
Against the backdrop of the provisions of the MultiChoice Agreement, the Senate probe panel would have to determine if, indeed, DStv has the capability to provide Pay-As-You-View service since it claims to have different equipments that render different services in the various coverage areas where it operates.
The ad-hoc committee also has the responsibility to unearth all MultiChoice Service, or aspects thereof, in whole or in part, that are available at all places in every country in which MultiChoice provides Service.
Where the ad-hoc committee finds that MultiChoice, indeed, has the equipment and capability to offer the PAYV of PAYG service, it must make a recommendation to the upper chamber for adoption, directing the PayTV company to introduce the service immediately for the benefit and satisfaction of Nigerian subscribers.
Dr. Tabiowo is the Special Assistant (Press) to the President of the Senate and writes from Abuja.
By Ahmad Shehu
There’s no doubt that the Hon. Minister of FCT, Mal Mohammed Musa Bello is not as corrupt as the other Ministers of the Federal Republic, but they’re other aspects of his leadership styles that are worst than when you have a corrupt Minister.
To start with, the Minister put up a face as someone who does not have attachments to the office, but one wonders why he will conveniently find a way of satisfying those he sees as capable of exposing his inefficiencies and lack of emotional intelligence to occupy office of the Hon. Minister or any office that will require serious interactions and risk taking. The Minister’s quest to portray himself as a righteous person, but allowed his children to be all over the offices in FCT, looking for contracts and other favors also questions his stance as one who does not want any form of family interference from his family and friends.
There’s a director who has told several people within the FCT, how the Hon. Minister often call him to ensure that his associates are well taken care of in terms of contracts allocation and other benefits. It’s no longer news that the Minister throws tantrums and go to the extent of throwing objects at anyone who may have offended him once he is in this state that is not expected of a public office holder, anything within his reach becomes an object to either threw at the other person or people or just smashed them on the floor. A look at the minister’s daily schedule shows 97% of his activities around receiving visitors, neglecting projects supervision and other urgent matters. This explains why files and other correspondences can spend months on attended to.
The Minister in his smart way always ensures that only mails from the presidency and other critical stakeholders are attended to. This is one of his ways of showing the President that he is working. The Minister has singlehandedly issued land allocation to individuals and groups whom he thinks can expose his inefficiencies, and this he has been doing consistently. There are instances he personally took allocations to people in the villa just to always pave way for him to see the President whenever he wants. How else, can we understand a Minister whose inaction has caused the FCTA revenue loss, certificates of occupancy are not being signed to generate revenue and to worsen the situation the Almighty emperor of Abuja closed the land application office of the lands department with the flimsy excuse that people are pressurizing him to allocate lands to them.
The Accelerated Area Council and Senatorial insurance schemes (AACSEIS) has not been functioning even though it was relaunched making it difficult for the FCT to generate revenue from this huge potential. There is no longer approval for building plan in Area Council which is why there is hazard development. The issue of IPPIS is worrisome when payment is made to consultants as FCT has the capacity to have their own IPPIS and pay their own staff themselves.
Today the hospital management board that is supposed to be managed by a well qualified consultant is now being run by a medical officer with less than 5 years cognate medical experience. The FCT board of internal revenue is not left out of this mess, up till now there is no substantive head for the agency. It’s only during the time of Mall Musa Bello that we have the office of the Director of Treasury not having a substantive Director. Staff morale are down but because the active Labor unions has been compromised with land allocation and no one can challenge him.
This is about the first time in the history of the creation of the Federal Capital Territory where the Land use allocation committee report will spend over a year on the Minister’s desk without any action and he keeps allocating lands to those whom he perceive can have influence in his continued stay in office.
The city is running on auto pilot with the Minister’s lip service attention to only services that will catch the attention of the President and some other highly placed Nigerians and foreigners, example of these services are Street lights, cleaning of the Airport road and some greening and construction of roads, other administrative actions can spend months no matter the urgency in his office without him being bothered.
How can one explain the administrative recklessness under the current Minister where the Managing Director of Abuja Market Management Council still enjoys full salary and all allowances 18 months after being deployed from the organization to report in the director of Human resources office. The redeployed MD still enjoys newspapers, driver, security, gardeners, cleaners are being paid from the lean resources of the organization, this has severally been brought to the Hon. Ministers attention without any corresponding action.
Posting the MD to the Director of Human Resources office was an error as he was never engaged by the administration directly, he was appointed as MD and should have been fired if he was found wanting after serving in that capacity for over seven years.
Because management staff are fully aware of his short tempered and lack of emotional control and low managerial ability, they just listen to his directives, and do as they wish knowing fully well that he can act beyond scattering things on his table whenever he is angry.
One of the victim of the Bello hypocrisy was Dr Tope Ajakaye, the Permanent Secretary who resumed work with him in 2015. DR Ajakaye who saw the Minister as a replica of the President in the Area of fight against corruption thought they were on the same page and did everything humanly possible to ensure that the staff of the administration imbibe the new culture and since change is one thing that human beings wants, this made the entire workforce and the media to hate the Permanent Secretary as he was seen as one who does not have their interest at heart.
Soon after Dr Ajakaye retired from service, the Minister donated Five Million Naira to the FCT Press corps just to demonstrate to them that Ajakaye was the person holding back what they ought to have gotten and this followed by other gratifications to the press corps just so they won’t report any negative story from the FCT.
Moral bankruptcy is what the Hon Minister has which is why most of the guests who visited him never get what they asked for no matter the merit of the request so long as he has nothing at stake or anyone up there to please. The resources of the administration are being used to satisfy personal interests across board.
One wonders why it has been a herculean task for the Minister to appoint replacement for some directors who have since retired from service, a situation that has made a department as sensitive as treasury to be without a substantive director for over 4 years. We never had Directors on acting capacity like we have in the current dispensation.
The city is fast becoming a refuse dump site because of the inactivity of the Minister. The menace of Okada riders all over the place is what has made Abuja fast becoming one of the headquarters of a lawless Capital city, the more officials try to remove them, the more they come in droves. Abuja is becoming a slum where building is now being erected on green land, sewage line and the rest.
Ahmad Shehu writes from Abuja and can be reached through: [email protected]
Reuben Abati’s Revolt Against Broadcasting’s Titular Conventions – By Farooq Kperogi
by Edit
written by Edit
Abuja – Former presidential spokesman and ARISE TV anchor, Dr. Reuben Abati
stirred a conversation in Nigeria’s journalism circles a few days ago when he upbraided an on-the-scene Arise TV correspondent by the name of Mary Chinda for addressing him as “Reuben” instead of “Dr. Abati.”
In Western broadcasting conventions, which Nigerian broadcasters have adopted, status, positional, and titular differentials are bracketed on air among colleagues. It’s an intentional inversion of the norm of everyday interactions where social superiors, older people, and unfamiliar people are typically addressed by their titles and last names unless they give permission to be called by their first names.
Addressing people by their first names signifies interpersonal familiarity, friendship, absence of power distance, and coevality.
During stand-ups (a part of the broadcast, often at the end, where the reporter appears at the scene and talks to the anchorperson in the studio), Western broadcasting convention requires reporters and anchorpersons to address each other by their first names. In my broadcast writing classes here in America, I penalize students who flout this rule in their scripts.
Abati studied Theater Arts, not Journalism, and was a print journalist for most of his professional life, so he can be forgiven for his lack of familiarity with broadcast conventions.
But I disagree with people who think his pushback against the culture of irreverent casualness in address in broadcast conventions is triggered by titular vainglory. The fact that a professional culture is entrenched in the West is no reason to accept it as a divinely ordained, inviolable article of faith in Nigeria.
Every culture has a right to insist that professional conventions show sensitivity to local customs and quotidian traditions. Because of the entrenched power asymmetries in relational encounters in the Nigerian society, the first-name convention in broadcast journalism has always seemed to me rather contrived and anomalous.
I bet that Chinda doesn’t call Abati by his first name outside of on-air interactions. But an imported, culturally outlandish convention requires her to do so during broadcasts. In a sense, neither Abati nor Chinda is wrong. The problem lies with Nigerian broadcasters’ inability to tweak an inherited Western journalistic convention and make it Nigerian.
There’s no reason why there should be one unalterable broadcast convention, particularly one that is nurtured by an across-the-board, discourteous informality—at least from the point of view of most Nigerian cultures.
In print journalism, for instance, there are two broad conventions in the use of titles in news copy. The Associated Press Style, which we like to call the bible of American journalism, forbids the use of courtesy titles such as “Mr.,” “Mrs.,” “Ms.,” and “Miss.” It also limits the use of professional and academic titles such as “Dr.” and “PhD” to occasions when such titles help to lend credibility to what expert sources say.
The New York Times and the Washington Post, on the other hand, use courtesy titles and honorifics, although the New York Times recently removed them for their pop culture stories because they found “the use of courtesy titles to be distancing.”
It betrays an absence of cultural imagination and creativity to always unquestioningly mimic everything from the West. When the Guardian in Lagos instituted the singularly boneheaded “Simply Mr.” titular policy (which said every male name would be prefixed with the title “Mr.” irrespective of professional, academic, or cultural attainments—with the exception of Chief Obafemi Awolowo, Mallam Aminu Kano, and Dr. Nnamdi Azikiwe) they were simply sheepishly copying the West.
It didn’t take long for the policy to be dropped because it instigated a strong resistance from Nigeria’s cultural and intellectual elites.
Now, digital-native publications like Premium Times and Peoples Gazette have resurrected this unimaginative aping of Western titular conventions, and routinely prefix bland western courtesy titles to every news source.
When I read stories talking about “Mr. Obasanjo,” “Mr. Buhari,” “Mr. Alex Ekweme,” “Mr “Goodluck Jonathan,” “Mr. Dangiwa Umar,” or “Mr Attahiru Jega” in a Nigerian news medium for a Nigerian audience, I cringe at the creativity deficit and imitative buffoonery that that reveals.
In Nigeria, some people’s titles are an inextricable part of their identities. Removing their titles risks getting them confused with other people who share similar names as them, especially because studies have shown that when people read online, they often don’t read linearly, i.e., from the beginning, middle, to the end; they jump around the page.
Productive creativity comes from an introspective self-consciousness of one’s culture and environment and crafting conventions to show sensitivity to and appreciation of the uniqueness of the culture and the environment.
An example of that is Mallam Mohammed Haruna’s little style pamphlet he prepared for the Daily Trust, which has a unique and creative take on titles in Nigeria. He recommends that when uniquely Nigerian titles like “Mallam,” “Alhaji,” “Chief,” “Asiwaju,” “Prince,” “Princess,” etc. are used in news stories, they should be used with the full name on first reference and first name only in subsequent references.
This is a reversal of Western convention where courtesy titles and honorifics are used with the full name on first reference and last name only in subsequent references. His reasoning for the reversal of the Western convention is unassailable. He said in all Nigerian cultures, titles are personal achievements that are often tied to the individual, not the family.
If Mohammed Abdullahi goes to Mecca on hajj, the glory is his, not his father’s, so it makes sense to refer to him as “Alhaji Mohammed Abdullahi” on first reference and “Alhaji Mohammed” in subsequent references. This is even more true of women. To refer to a Chief Alice Abiola as “Chief Abiola” in subsequent references is preposterous because it’s Alice, not Abiola, who is knighted with a chieftaincy title.
Of course, when we use Western courtesy titles and honorifics, it’s fine to refer to people’s titles and last names only in subsequent references.
Just like in the media, universities in different countries have different traditions of address for university teachers. In the UK, lecturers encourage students, including undergraduates, to address them by their first names.
That’s a no-no in the United States. Here, undergraduates must address their teachers by the teachers’ titles and last name. Only colleagues—and sometimes doctoral students—can address teachers by their first names.
However, although it’s the norm for colleagues to address each other by their first names, I couldn’t bring myself to address a Nigerian colleague of mine here in the US who is old enough to be my father by his first name— even when he insisted. It didn’t roll off the tongue easily, so I pleaded with him to allow me to violate the norm. He understood.
A relative of mine who spent the greatest portion of his academic career in the United States was perplexed when he relocated to Nigeria a few years ago and found that his colleagues at the university he taught were calling each other “prof.” “doctor,” etc. and weren’t enthused that he called them by their first names or introduced himself by his first name.
He asked me what was going on because he was genuinely puzzled, having been culturally uprooted from Nigeria for decades. After I broke it down to him, he agreed that every culture has a right to fashion its conventions according to its peculiarities. He has now become habituated to calling people by their titles.
My mother-in-law, who is American, loves this part of what I call Nigeria’s titular onomastics, that is, the practice where titles become substitutes for names. Being American, she had trouble remembering many Nigerian names, and even more trouble pronouncing them with native phonetic fidelity. She tells me she is grateful that it’s considered the height of respect to simply call Nigerian men by such honorifics as “Mallam,” “Chief,” “Alhaji,” etc. and the women “Mallama,” “Hajia,” “Madam,” etc. without ever mentioning their real names.
Dr. Reuben Abati is challenging Nigerian broadcasters to question their received, formulaic conventions. Sometimes it takes an outsider to prod us to think outside the box in order to upend staid traditions, subvert taken-for-granted assumptions, and upturn settled, ossified, and often faulty certainties.
By Titus Foga
We read on the social media the promotion by one Joe Igbokwe of a injudicious opinion he copied from one Kurtis Adigba who said Governor Samuel Ortom of Benue state will lose his seat if his colleague in Ebonyi state, David Nweze Umahi’s sack by the court is upheld.
Igbokwe, I learnt is the Senior Special Assistant on Drainages in Lagos state.
That is why it baffles me why a supposed enlightened public persona in a metropolitan state like Lagos will choose to align on an ignoble adventure of promoting misinformation cooked by someone who obviously lacks knowledge of what is happening in the body polity of this nation.
Of course, keeping quiet on such calculated fabrication is certainly a disservice to unsuspected members of the public and most especially, fans of a very popular, dodged and performing Governor of Benue state, Samuel Ortom, hence the need to put records straight.
Let it be known to Adigba and Igbokwe that Governor Samuel Ortom was re-elected for a fresh mandate as Governor of the Food Basket state in 2019 on the platform of the People’s Democratic Party.
In clarity, Governor Ortom dumped the All Progressives Congress APC on whose platform he won his first term in office as Governor in 2018. He legally went through all the legitimate processes set up by the People’s Democratic Party PDP constitution/guidelines, INEC guidelines and the 1999 constitution of the FRN as amended to obtain his ticket before going ahead to win the gubernatorial polls in 2019. This is to say that Ortom cannot be lumped in the same camp with what has befallen Governor Umahi.
Therefore, if Adigba whose misguided opinion Igbokwe is impulsively promoting is a follower of political developments in the country, he would have known that Ortom won his election in 2019 under PDP and has nothing, absolutely nothing to do with APC because of his popularity in Benue and this country.
This outing by Adigba and Igbokwe is obviously an absolute chimera. Whosoever sent them on this contemptible outing be reminded that Ortom’s second term mandate is firmly planted on the platform of PDP and has no links with the leprous APC.
This is to say that Governor Ortom did not offend any known legal procedure to become Governor. If he did, the many tricks to oust him by the Fulani cabal would have succeeded. That is why, at the moment, he is so busy delivering good governance to the people of Benue state.
It is instructive to advise detractors cooking up such falsehood targeted at Governor Ortom to distract him that it won’t fly. Let me advise APC apologists looking for others to mourn with them should look elsewhere because this Benue Governor has moved. His eyes are already fixed at winning the 2023 polls for his party, the PDP.
Foga is a Public Affairs Analyst and writes from Makurdi, Benue State.
By Titus Foga
Theodore Roosevelt, the 26th president of the United States once said, “Here is your country. Cherish these natural wonders, cherish the natural resources, cherish the history and romance as a sacred heritage, for your children and your children’s children. Do not let selfish men or greedy interests skin your country of its beauty, its riches or its romance”.
This typifies the life of Samuel Ortom, the 5th democratically elected Governor of Benue State. Since he came to power, he has continued to demonstrate uncommon characteristics of a true nationalist.
His unvarnished passion for his state and country has so portrayed him erroneously in the eyes of many as a stubborn leader.
His boldness and fearless posture for consistently confronting the leadership at the centre and desperately finding measures to protect his people and state has further made him look like such. But this is a wrong judgement.
Ortom has demonstrated other distinctive leadership traits, sedulously practising all these as a leader.
Take his signature cap (colours) for instance. It is the ‘Unity Cap.’
The multicolours on the Unity Cap symbolises first, the three traditional colours of the dominant ethnicities in his state. These are the black and white which represents the Tiv. Red and black for the Idoma nation while the Igede that is the third-largest tribe in the state has its colours of blue and black well imprinted. The nation’s green white green colours wrap up the unification message Governor Ortom preaches.
The Governor of the Food Basket state is so proud of his heritage that hardly can one see him, home or overseas without him adorning his signature cap beautifully made with the unity colours.
The designers of these attires and the cap in particular are local artisans from this state.
Moreover, the producers of these attires, the local artisans are fully patronized and are making good returns as hundreds of these dresses are occasionally ordered by the Governor and his administration for special government functions.
This means that the Governor to a large extent, has sufficiently demonstrated his adherence to patronizing local products.
Furthermore, the magnitude Ortom’s administration is patronizing Innoson Vehicles is equally a pointer that he indeed is poised to encourage home business.
Innoson Vehicle Manufacturing Co. Ltd. is a Nigerian automobile manufacturer with headquarters in Nnewi, Anambra State, Nigeria. It is founded by Chief Innocent Chukwuma Nwala.
Findings have shown that between 2017 to date, over a hundred Innoson Vehicles, have been purchased and supplied to Benue state Government for use by its officials and traditional rulers.
Just last week, the State Executive Council, approved the purchase of yet another 30 Innoson Charis Brand to be assigned to officials of the state.
These motivational gestures Governor Ortom is helping to build our economy and has depicted him as a true nationalist who keeps demonstrating his commitment to supporting Nigerian-made products.
In addition, the Benue state government over the past six years has succeeded in redirecting the thinking of the people back to the farm. The governor believes that the state has an advantage in agriculture and must be maximally utilised. Civil Servants and political appointees have continued to make gains with the proceeds from their farms. This is beginning to help them stop their overreliance on buying food, and in some instances, processed commodities in the market for consumption. A good percentage of the people of the state now cultivate their farms.
Although the government’s decision to declare public holidays during the cropping and harvest seasons were resisted, for over two years now, many civil servants and Government appointees are feeding their families from the food they are producing on their farms. This, it has been discovered has yielded tremendous results to the benefit of the people who took advantage of it.
Despite the challenges occasioned by activities of marauding Fulani herdsmen across the state, there is still evidence of huge harvests among some Benue markets. Although this could be better seen if the federal government takes steps and attend to the cries of Governor Ortom to ensure that majority of the farming population of the state stuck in Internally Displaced camps away from their communities are aided to go back to their ancestral lands.
This has been the Governor’s consistent anger against the federal government of President Muhammadu Buhari. It has never been personal. Ortom like many other people feel, and rightly too that the President has exhibited unsatisfactory conduct in handling the insecurity challenges affecting the state, nay Nigeria. This is what should be understood.
Ortom’s anger is ably justified. He has continued to ask why invading killer herdsmen are being pampered while a section of his people are habitually being prevented by same Fulanis from accessing their land for cultivation.
Thus, when a leader is consistent in promoting his heritage, standing for his people and carving a niche for himself for vowing to die for same people, then, he can only be believed to be an ideal nationalist.
It is with this in mind that I conclude that Governor Ortom stands out unarguably
as a true nationalist in leadership. And so I ask, could such a man so deeply in love with his state and nation be considered otherwise just because of political considerations? The answer, as far as I know, is a big no. He is one leader whose love for Benue and Nigeria is unparalleled. Let’s support him
Foga is a Public Affairs analyst and contributed this piece from Makurdi.
By Chido Nwakanma
Arise TV The Morning Show presenter Dr Reuben Abati clearly went overboard and defamed his colleague Mary Chinda on air in the now infamous exchange about the use of first names. If it was a joke, it turned out sour.
Stakeholders have been up in arms. The din is loud and overwhelming.
It is a function of the strength of that programme and station that the issue gripped national attention so much.
Conversations around it have brought up many points. They include first names by broadcasters on air: is it a universal norm such as the inverted pyramid in news reporting? Or is there room for cultural peculiarities? How far can hosts go with jests on air?
AriseTV News can sort it out in several ways. One very unusual but intelligent method would be for the senior person to make it up to his junior on air. It should satisfy all stakeholders.
Please note that the junior here, Mary Chinda, is as professional as they come. She holds first and second degrees in mass communication and is pursuing the ultimate academic diadem. Chinda has stacked up experience at Enugu Broadcasting Corporation, Plus TV Africa and News Central TV. She is, as such no greenhorn.
Significantly, I have seen many commentators try to degrade Dr Reuben Abati by claiming that he is not a trained journalist or not prepared for broadcasting. Debatable claims.
Reuben is as trained in journalism as they come. He has spent more than 30 years serving in high editorial positions and winning all available awards in the profession in his area. Those awards are validation of competence and professionalism. Not a journalist? Yet he was Chairman of the Editorial Board of The Guardian, columnist and editorial board member at Thisday and now anchor at AriseTV News. Please.
Broadcasters say the use of first names is the norm in their industry. I reached out to veterans such as Mr Kevin Ejiofor, former Ag DG of FRCN, Nnaemeka Maduegbuna, formerly of NTA, Sola Omole, and Senator Chris Anyanwu, who owns broadcast organs. Three of four responded.
They affirmed the use of first names in addressing colleagues. Mr Ejiofor stated, “Of course, that’s the norm. I had often wondered why the young lady (not the Abiola) always addressed him as Dr Abati on The Morning Show. Of course, conventionally, there’s such a thing as a house style. I had wondered if Arise was introducing its own house style to ‘dobale’ for ‘seniors’.”
Senator Chris Anyanwu: “The convention that I know of is to call people by their first names. The idea is to promote a nice, collegial atmosphere. No one ever addresses a co-anchor by Mr… Such formality is best left off the air”.
On cultural variations, Mr Ejiofor stated, “I’m afraid I’m not aware that it does. But then, with conventions being a matter of choice and long-standing habit, there’s little room for a definitive yes or no. For example, no one objected to the young lady calling Reuben Dr Abati, as far as I know. I felt odd about it but 🤷🏿♂️. And this is Nigeria.”
And Maduegbuna: “There could be. However, it has to be contextual. Naming in broadcasting is akin to bylines in print journalism. Titles are ranks are not usually used. Back then in the late seventies, late James Audu, pioneer Director of NTA News ( grade level 15) and Late Joan O’dwyer (grade level 9) as a news anchor pair, used their first names on air. It was not just that Audu was a level 15 officer, he was the boss of the organization.
Reuben should be conversant with the norm.”
The Morning Show is an exciting programme that has gripped the imagination, attention and interest of viewers. The first-name use incident has availed critics and fans alike the opportunity to give feedback to the station and the presenters. They should please pay attention and take all the learnings. I will urge that they script the programme more closely to reduce off-the-handle displays that happen during exclusive reliance on live shows.
“Simply Mr.” was the innovation of The Guardian in 1983 to tackle the Nigerian obsession with titles. It died a year later on the eve of the Decree 4 trials when Chief Rotimi Williams as the paper’s counsel voiced his year-long resentment at the insult of the denial of his title in the pages of the newspaper. Culture fights against the quest for egalitarian usage in titles in Nigeria.
Note that the use of first names is an ongoing debate in some organisations in Corporate Nigeria and has become a riddle for their internal communications teams. One bank CEO insisted on such usage for himself, staff and customers. Well, his staff tried it with a high net worth customer in a South-South state.
The High Chief took offence and exception to have customer service representatives demean him. The bank had to find exceptions to the rule.
However, the convention in broadcasting is to use first names. Will it bend to Nigeria? Not yet, and not desirable.
- Chido Nwakanma